1. "Prelude" 1:31
2. "Into the Unknown" Brandon Armstrong, Joshua Kaufman, Justin Rubenstein, Patrick McHale McHale Jack Jones 1:27
3. "You Have Beautiful Eyes" 1:31
4. "Pottsfield C.M." 1:30
5. "Patient is the Night" Armstrong, Kaufman, Rubenstein, McHale Chris Isaak 1:27
6. "Adelaide Parade" Collin Dean, Elijah Wood 1:37
7. "Money for School" 1:15
8. "Ms. Langtree's Lament" Janet Klein 2:27
9. "Potatoes & Molasses" David V. Stevenson Dean 1:11
10. "Off to Bed" 1:05
11. "The Beast is Out There" Armstrong, Kaufman, Rubenstein, McHale Audrey Wasilewski 0:45
12. "The Highwayman" Jerron "Blind Boy" Paxton, Pendleton Ward Paxton 0:31
13. "A Courting Song" Armstrong, Kaufman, Rubenstein, McHale Petrojvic Blasting Company Frank Fairfield 1:20
14. "Endicott Manor" 1:02
15. "The Journey Begins" 0:50
16. "Half-Moon River" 0:57
17. "McLaughlin Bros. Jug Band" 0:40
18. "Over the Garden Wall" Armstrong, Kaufman, Rubenstein, McHale Jones 1:45
19. "Send Me a Peach" 2:02
20. "Adelaide's Trap" 2:11
21. "Like Ships" Wood, Shannyn Sossamon 0:29
22. "More Bones to Sort" 0:50
23. "Old North Wind" Mark Bodnar Bodnar 1:03
24. "Forward, Oneiroi" Armstrong, Kaufman, Rubenstein, McHale Deborah Voigt 1:31
25. "The Fight is Over" Armstrong, Kaufman, Rubenstein, McHale McHale 1:17
26. "Tiny Star" Eddika Organista 1:42
27. "Old Black Train" 2:13
28. "The Old Mill" 1:24
29. "Come Wayward Souls" Armstrong, Kaufman, Rubenstein, McHale Audio Clayton, Samuel Ramey 1:51
30. "Potatus et Molassus" Armstrong, Kaufman, Rubenstein, McHale Clayton 2:18
31. "One is a Bird" Shirley Jones 1:40
32. "Black Train / End Credits" 0:37
Total length: 43:59
Digital bonus tracks
No. Title Lyrics Music Artist(s) Length
33. "The Clouded Annals of History" 0:34
34. "Can't You See I'm Lonely" Felix F. Feist Harry Armstrong C.W. Stoneking 1:19
35. "Shine On" Jack Norworth Nora Bayes C.W. Stoneking 2:18
36. "Everything is Nice and Fine" Judah Nelson 1:21
37. "Halloween Halftime" 2:17
38. "Two Old Cat" 0:56
39. "The Jolly Woodsman"
